Luna Story (nonogram‪)‬ 4+

Finished 19 of 24 big puzzles on iPad now using Apple Pencil works great. Following comments relate to iPhone. Game is best of class either way. Luna Story 1 has the unique feature of providing the option to use a cross shaped controller to select a square to be marked. This makes it possible to choose the exactly correct spot every time with zero errors. On other iPhone based Nonogram games I almost always touch at least one or more wrong squares just because as the grid size increases, the size of a square is smaller than the finger tip you use to touch and select it, so this Luna controller works great. You can use left and right thumbs to move the selection point and choose whether to fill or mark as empty simultaneously. If you’re near the edge, you can navigate to the opposite side just by moving one square past the end. So this feature alone is great. Plus the artwork and music are very nice. I paid the fee on day one to remove ads and support the developer. Also, multiple colors appear without having to manually select them, so even the smaller, simpler puzzles have a more recognizable image when complete. I learned to play Nonograms on a 15” MacBook Pro, and this is the best, most polished, beautiful and enjoyable implementation I’ve found for the iPhone. The only improvement I’d like to suggest is whether the number dimmed for squares already filled could be a bit more legible.

So glad I found this game. I had been playing another nonogram game that was so stingy that basically I could only play one new puzzle a day. This one has no energy limit and very (relatively) few ads. No penalties for misclicks is also nice. Love the 20x20 size and the large storybook puzzles. Overall, very relaxing and enjoyable.

While I’m giving it 5 stars over all, a couple of flaws…first, the typos are pervasive. I thought maybe it was a translation issue, but now I think it is just lack of proof-reading. Second, the very first time I tried to play it after loading, it was so buggy as to be almost unplayable. Not sure what happened there, but fortunately when I opened it the next time, there were no problems (and haven’t been since).

I love nonograms and play several other similar apps so I really wanted to love this game, but it’s so buggy that it’s unplayable. The tutorial text doesn’t disappear when you hit “next” so I can’t even watch the tutorial as the text just layers and obscures what’s underneath. I don’t like playing where the x’s fill in automatically, but if I turn off autofill, I cannot fill in spaces at all. If I accidentally fill in my own x in an incorrect spot, the auto check marks it as a red x rather than a filled in space, so I can never correct the mistake and fix the puzzle. I also cannot figure out how to erase what I’ve put in a box which is a huge oversight. I have no idea what the pen vs finger feature is that brings up that little menu bar, but every time I move the bar to highlight a different area, it duplicates itself. If the game was playable, I’m sure I’d enjoy it, but all of these bugs made it tedious to attempt an otherwise easy 10x10. If they’re fixed later on, I’d certainly play and reassess.